Your Cart is Empty

Anonymous Potato Reviews

Below is a list of all of our reviews on feel free to filter to find a review that is useful for you.
Based on 311 reviews
Hilarious gift

Sent to my fav COD streamer because he’s a potato! Great lil gift for laughs! Sent quick and loved the add ons!

Surprise Box
Cameron Green

Twas lovely

Old As Shit Sash
Evelyn Gilmore

Love it

Surprise Box
Elizabeth Kitchens

Great gift my sister and law loved it It was a big hit!!!!!!

Epic Gift

Turned out perfect! My friend loved it.

Mail A Potato Face
Ashley Riddle
Perfect Gift

Sent one to my husband as an inside joke. Perfect delivery. Worth every penny.

Mail A Potato Face
jim gilligan
Great Fun Product and Excellent Customer Service

Great for sending to family and friends who live far away. Customer servie was promt and helpful.

Mail A Potato Face
Cousin Who Sends Potatoes
Fresh potato with my face on it!

I ordered a potato with my face on it to be delivered to my cousin. It was awesome! It shipped immediately, arrived promptly, and made lots of laughs.


It was for my daughter’s birthday. It did exactly what I wanted it to do.

Surprise Box
Misty Williams
Best surprise gift ever!

On Tuesday, March 29th I ordered a potato from Anonymous Potato for my moms birthday on April 11th and had this random couple’s picture printed on the potato (thanks Google for the random “middle aged couple” image) with a note saying “Happy Birthday Jeanette. Miss you. Tell Eddie hello.” and I signed it with random names I picked “Paul and Jeannie”. See, I expected the order to take 2 weeks or so to get delivered. Much to my surprise I get an email on Wednesday, March 30th (the day after ordering) that my shipment was on the way. Then, Friday April 1st (April Fools Day), the tater had been delivered. Let me just say this was like two gifts and one. My mom was so confused by this random couple she didn’t know that was sending her a potato for her birthday. To her home address! But she absolutely loved it and even text me a photo with the potato in her lap like a little lap dog and said “I don’t know these people but best gift ever. I love my potato.” She told everyone she knew and even asked around if anyone knew these people. This went on until her birthday on April 11 when I came clean and sent her screenshots of my order confirmation showing it was me that ordered the potato.

I shared my experience on Facebook and in a group chat with my coworkers and everyone got a good laugh. Turns out one of my coworkers birthdays was coming up. When I told her about my mom‘s potato she responded “who would send a potato and why? That’s so silly.” So obviously my work team sent her a potato for her birthday. When she got it she said I get it now this was such a joy to open.”

Best Birthday Gift Ever

That’s what my friend said when they opened their potato. Lots of laughs. Definitely worth the purchase.

Best Birthday Gift Ever

“This is the best birthday gift ever, I’m never getting rid of it” was the response from my friend when they opened their potato. So worth it. So much fun!

Mail A Potato Face
Anthony Ferrigno
Brothers birthday gift

My brother loved the gift, he thought it was hilarious.

Surprise Box
Kathleen Belei
Spud Durst

Turned out great. Thanks!

Mail A Potato Face
Kristen Wymer

Mail A Potato Face

Perfect for that special someone

I had been wanting to send someone a potato for a while, so when my best friend’s birthday came around I knew it was the right time. It came a day or two after her birthday, and she sent me some hysterical messages and ultimately loved it. I think mostly for the surprise factor - and there is a lot to be said for a good surprise. It was one hundred percent worth it, 10 stars out of five, and I can’t wait to send another.

Surprise Box
Christina Rainville
Poorly made 👎🏼

Wasn’t impressed with the fact that the picture was just just printed out on a plain piece of paper and barely glued on 👎🏼

Mail A Potato Face
Brandon Gauthier

My brother laughed harder than I’ve heard him laugh in 4 years.

Mail A Potato Face
Anna Deese
So much fun!

So easy to do and my niece LOVED the surprise. Hilarious gift!

Birthday Queen Sash
Robert Hardin-Leeth
Great gift-timing was off

I got a potato and birthday queen sash for my friend. I asked for it to be mailed on a specific date, but those instructions were not followed, so she got the present several weeks early. She still loved it, but I was a little disappointed by the timing issue.

Mail A Potato Face
Angela Buchanan
Hilarious birthday gift

I thought it was hilarious. The recipient didn’t. He was annoyed. Which made it even funnier to me.

It was just a printed picture and written in sharpie. Nothing you couldn’t do yourself. However - would you ever? No. You wouldn’t do it yourself. Packaged well. I mean cmon- it’s a mailed potato. Hilarious.

Got a good laugh but poor quality

Mission accomplished, I got a good laugh out of giving this gift, however, the photo looked like my 5 year old modged podged a photo to a potato. It had a wrinkle or two in it and it really didn't look like the samples on the website (see photo). However, it is a real potato, so hard to get a flat spot, I get it. I would do it again, but I just won't expect much for the quality...the main point was to get a good rise out of the person I sent it to and that certainly happened!

Mail A Potato Face
Sawyer Williams
Fuggin perfect, 10 out of 10, would buy again.

The homie opened that ish up and was like "bruuuuuh". Nuff said.

Mail A Potato Face
Lexi Gruich

It was great!

Mail A Custom Anonymous Potato

Sign up for our Newsletter