delivering incredible moments

0

Your Cart is Empty

Anonymous Potato Reviews

Below is a list of all of our reviews on Judge.me feel free to filter to find a review that is useful for you.
Based on 323 reviews
93%
(299)
7%
(21)
1%
(3)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
J
Mail A Potato Face
James Eldridge
Loved it.

The instagram and twitter addresses on the flyer included were wrong though.

J
Surprise Box
James Tuttle
Amazing and fun

Great surprise and fun gift for my brother! His favorite and certainly most unique Christmas gift!

I love it

I always wanted to be a burrito! Now I can be. It is the perfect weight and very soft. It could be a little longer but is otherwise the perfect lounge blanket.

It’s never perfect

I wish it was on a black couch it would be like the casting

M
Mail A Custom Anonymous Potato
Michelle Anderson
Hilarious!

I sent this as a 30th birthday gift for a friend, and he was delighted. A+, would highly recommend!

J
Mail A Potato Face
Jen Meyer

Mail A Potato Face

L
Black Explosion Box
Lori Sadler
Best reaction EVER!!

I wasn’t going to buy an exploding box, but my nephew’s fiancé told my recently married niece to be on the lookout for a congratulations potato from me. So, naturally , I had to up my game. This box was absolute perfection. She even filmed her opening the box and screaming when the butterflies flew out. 11/10 would send to another friend who does not know of Anonymous Potato.

Everything worked out terrific

S
Mail A Potato Face
Stephanie Hogancamp
Poe Tato

It was great to watch her open her potato. It truly brought her joy, coupled with disbelief at the absurdity of receiving a potato in the mail. I’m so glad I did this!

Engagement Potato

I sent this to my nephew and his fiancé to congratulate them on their engagement. At first, they thought it was from my mom(which makes me laugh). After realizing it was from me, they got a good laugh and said it was the best engagement gift they had received.

Better than Cookies

This is the gift that keeps on giving! I surprised my bestie with a potato with her face on it and now she’s hiding it around her house in a different spot each day for her husband to find. This was way better than sending cookies!

N
Surprise Box
Niko Rolon

Surprise Box

Hilarious gift

Sent to my fav COD streamer because he’s a potato! Great lil gift for laughs! Sent quick and loved the add ons!

C
Surprise Box
Cameron Green

Twas lovely

E
Old As Shit Sash
Evelyn Gilmore
:)

Love it

E
Surprise Box
Elizabeth Kitchens
Awesome

Great gift my sister and law loved it It was a big hit!!!!!!

Epic Gift

Turned out perfect! My friend loved it.

A
Mail A Potato Face
Ashley Riddle
Perfect Gift

Sent one to my husband as an inside joke. Perfect delivery. Worth every penny.

j
Mail A Potato Face
jim gilligan
Great Fun Product and Excellent Customer Service

Great for sending to family and friends who live far away. Customer servie was promt and helpful.

C
Mail A Potato Face
Cousin Who Sends Potatoes
Fresh potato with my face on it!

I ordered a potato with my face on it to be delivered to my cousin. It was awesome! It shipped immediately, arrived promptly, and made lots of laughs.

Perfection!

It was for my daughter’s birthday. It did exactly what I wanted it to do.

M
Surprise Box
Misty Williams
Best surprise gift ever!

On Tuesday, March 29th I ordered a potato from Anonymous Potato for my moms birthday on April 11th and had this random couple’s picture printed on the potato (thanks Google for the random “middle aged couple” image) with a note saying “Happy Birthday Jeanette. Miss you. Tell Eddie hello.” and I signed it with random names I picked “Paul and Jeannie”. See, I expected the order to take 2 weeks or so to get delivered. Much to my surprise I get an email on Wednesday, March 30th (the day after ordering) that my shipment was on the way. Then, Friday April 1st (April Fools Day), the tater had been delivered. Let me just say this was like two gifts and one. My mom was so confused by this random couple she didn’t know that was sending her a potato for her birthday. To her home address! But she absolutely loved it and even text me a photo with the potato in her lap like a little lap dog and said “I don’t know these people but best gift ever. I love my potato.” She told everyone she knew and even asked around if anyone knew these people. This went on until her birthday on April 11 when I came clean and sent her screenshots of my order confirmation showing it was me that ordered the potato.

I shared my experience on Facebook and in a group chat with my coworkers and everyone got a good laugh. Turns out one of my coworkers birthdays was coming up. When I told her about my mom‘s potato she responded “who would send a potato and why? That’s so silly.” So obviously my work team sent her a potato for her birthday. When she got it she said I get it now this was such a joy to open.”

Best Birthday Gift Ever

That’s what my friend said when they opened their potato. Lots of laughs. Definitely worth the purchase.

Best Birthday Gift Ever

“This is the best birthday gift ever, I’m never getting rid of it” was the response from my friend when they opened their potato. So worth it. So much fun!

A
Mail A Potato Face
Anthony Ferrigno
Brothers birthday gift

My brother loved the gift, he thought it was hilarious.

Sign up for our Newsletter