FREE U.S. SHIPPING ON ORDERS OF $50+

0

Your Cart is Empty

Anonymous Potato Reviews

Below is a list of all of our reviews on Judge.me feel free to filter to find a review that is useful for you.
Based on 257 reviews
93%
(239)
7%
(17)
0%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
A
Mail A Potato Face
Amy Bowers
Unique gift

Fantastic gift!

S
Surprise Box
SHILEEN FEENEY-VIENNEAU
College Reminder

I sent my son a potato with a message that said, "Call your Mom, college man!" It was great!

D
Mail A Potato Face
Davida Kravetskaya
Funny and cute!

Very funny gift and definitely unexpected!

S
Mail A Potato Face
SHILEEN FEENEY-VIENNEAU
Surprise for Dad

The potato was a hit! My 78 year old dad laughed and loved it. It got posted on social media by his wife for their friends. It was totally worth it.

K
Mail A Potato Face
Karlyn Mizzoni

Hilarious

Shipping issue

Not really the company's fault i suppose but it arrived a few days later than expected and he was on vacation so it rotted before he could open it 😬

The recipient of this unusual gift was very surprised and happ.

A
Mail A Potato Face
Adelle Young

Mail A Potato Face

Super Fun!

The potato was a perfect pick me up for a friend with health issues. It arrived on time in perfect condition and she loved it!

R
Mail A Potato Face
Rachael Hudson
Fun

Such a fun and random way to surprise friends and family!

A
Surprise Box
Anonymous
A total surprise!

This was such a fun and unexpected surprise! I mean, it’s a potato! Can I be any more random? Ha! Thanks for making me laugh and smile!

D
Birthday Queen Sash
Donald Baker
Hot potato

i hit a home run!!! Highly recommend….

Best find ever!!

I heard about this in a book and once I found out it was real I had to do it!!! I sent a potato to my brother for his birthday and I think that was the best call ever to ask me if I sent him a potato!!! Potato was there on time from the date I gave them. I never saw the potato but it got some great laughs!!! I did just the basic potato.

K
Mail A Potato Face
Kira Cope
It was amazing

It made my best friends day.

D
Mail A Potato Face
Denise Novick
So fun!

I sent potatoes with my face on them to my kids while they were away at summer camp and it was a huge hit! All the kids thought it was hysterical and so fun. I was a celebrity when I picked them up from camp. We hope to sprout them and plant them so the kids can have potato siblings one day. So fun!

A
Mail A Potato Face
Austin McMullen

Mail A Potato Face

Worked Great!

Butterflies busting out was simply amazing.

Spud surprised

I was really excited to find another usual gift. This kwel on the web but, when we opened it I have to admit my disappointment. The card was cute but nothing on it as to who it was from. The picture that should have been on the potato had popped of. The concept was cute , was lacking.

S
Potato Birthday Bundle
Susan DeVito
Godson

It was fast, efficient, and a fun gift. Loved it!

R
Mail A Potato Face
Ryan Ward
Hilarious Gift

Honestly, this gift kept our family laughing well after the gift arrived. It is a great, funny little story to bring up with friends and family :)

Wife & kids love it! Comfortable!

First off this blanket is surprisingly very comfortable! Very impressed with this product. The family got to wrap up like a Burrito!

B
Mail A Potato Face
Bryan Smith
Very Nice

You get exactly what is advertise, quite funny.

Mankini tater

Potato has lasted long past it's normal shelf life, and has been a center piece for conversation starting. Everyone who sees it compliments it and wants to know how to get a potato!

A
Surprise Box
Anthony Mazzoli
Great gag, or special gift!

I sent one to a friend just to confuse them, the other had a special picture for my other friend. It meant a lot to them, lol
. Always thinking about others is fun sometimes!

C
Surprise Box
Christine Rice
Awesome!

Got this for my 12yr old daughter. She absolutely loved it and couldn’t stop laughing! Thank you!!

Sign up for our Newsletter