Anonymous Potato Reviews

Below is a list of all of our reviews on Judge.me feel free to filter to find a review that is useful for you.
Based on 376 reviews
90%
(338)
7%
(25)
2%
(6)
0%
(0)
2%
(9)
T
Mail A Potato Face
Tracy Stern
Cheap

So cheap printing out a pic and pasting it on the potato. I could have done this for free.

Horrible

Their forum was confusing so I put my address in where they wanted the address it was to be sent to, they ignored all customer service requests, and then I never even received the potato. These people suck

Flop

Took 20 days to mail to VA- birthday was long over.
It was a flop

So close….

I had put special notes in there to omit the three “…” if they couldn’t be white in color. They were included as black circles. So the whole “inside” message was lost. Kinda sucked but the thought is what counts…right?!

Customer service sucks

No reply from customer service

The butterflies I ordered were broken!

They were supposed to be flying butterflies but because of the little plastic hooks being snapped, the rubber band in the middle couldn't connect to both sides and be twisted. I ordered them for my daughter's school Valentine gifts and they did not arrive in a timely manner so we were not able to give them out and when they did arrive many were broken.

Mail A Custom Anonymous Potato

A
Mail A Potato Face
Alicia Clifford
I CANCELLED MY ORDER AND YOU IGNORED EVERY MESSAGE AND SENT IT ANYWAY

GIVE ME MY REFUND, YOU JOKE OF A COMPANY

Mail A Custom Anonymous Potato

A
Surprise Box
Allison Whitmore
Gift for my Nephew

I sent a Christmas potato to my 4 year old nephew in New York and he thought it was the funniest thing. I think I started a new Christmas tradition.

J
Mail A Potato Face
Justin Brown

Mail A Potato Face

Mail A Custom Anonymous Potato

great

Recipient loved it

J
Father's Day Bundle
Jace Maris

Exactly what I wanted!

Mail A Custom Anonymous Potato

M
Mail A Potato Face
Melissa Shanley
Awesome but a bit $$

Potato turned out great and was a hit!

It’s ok

I like this service but most ads show a much bigger potato than what was sent. All three that I sent was about the size of a baseball and one of them was already getting soft.

D
Mail A Potato Face
Desirae Sanders
So cute!

My bestie loved her potato with my face on it. Great gift to send some laughs

W
Surprise Box
Whitney Mohr
Cute gift for the person who needs something a little different

I wish that the potato was edible. My friend loved it - it made her laugh.

S
Valentine Sweet Potato
Sarah Sweet Potato Gray
Amazing

Awesome gift for national sweet potato day, for which me and my friend exchange a small gift for every year as an inside joke. Perfect, and the photo on the sweet potato was of excellent quality.

M
Surprise Box
Melinda Ofarrell
Best customer service!

I had entered the wrong address for delivery and didn't notice until the next day. I emailed customer service and they quickly corrected my error. My grandson is still trying to figure out who in the world would have sent him a Happy Birthday potato for his 18th birthday!

Perfect! Arrived when I wanted it to and thoroughly confused the recipient!! Excellent. 100% will recommend to friends and family!

J
Surprise Box
Jennifer Lindemann
Surprise box

The birthday boy still can’t figure out who sent the potato.
You guys are good!

J
Mail A Custom Anonymous Potato
Jennifer Lindemann

I haven’t heard from the recipient yet.

Sign up for our Newsletter